Tuesday, March 13, 2012

New Orleans Saints bounty scandal may be considered a criminal organization



In recent weeks, The NFL have said that around 22-27 New Orleans Saints defensive players, as well as an assistant coach, upheld an illegal bounty program from 2009-2011 that included payments to players for causing game-ending injuries on the opposition.
Players are said to have been paid $1,500 for “knockouts” and $1,000 for being carted off the field, and the stakes went up in the playoffs.

Former defensive coordinator Gregg Williams, has recently admitted to his involvement in the program and has apologized. The Saints head coach Sean Payton and general manager Mickey Loomis have also released a statement taking “full responsibility” for the violations within the league.

The statements made by New Orleans Saints management and coaches are making it look very probable that they engaged in improper and coercive activities. Taking a look at the NFL’s current CBA, it includes detailed rules on how clubs and coaches can be penalized for violations of safeguards. Not all facts are currently known, and the NFLPA is undertaking a full review of the circumstances surrounding these reported violations of League rules.

Currently, the New Orleans Saints franchise, its players, coaches, and former player Gregg Williams are awaiting words on penalties from NFL Commissioner Roger Goodwell. However, there may be bigger consequences for those involved in this bounty scandal. The criminal defense attorneys and a former federal prosecutor have said that if the Saints did engage in the scandal that paid players to deliberately injure the opposition, then this situation could be considered a criminal organization.

As of right now, there has been no sign of federal law enforcement activity, and it is unlikely that local law enforcement would take up the case, “given the political sensitivities of tackling a case involving the beloved Saints”. However, the local federal attorney could assign a special prosecutor to investigate the case.

Football is known to be a violent sport, and there is a certain level of consent to the violence when a player steps out on to the field; however, this consent changes when there is an intentional effort to actually injure someone rather than actually tackle him or her. “The intent element is manifested by the money payments”. As well as local federal attorney’s possibly getting involved, the individual players who believe they were hurt as part of the Saints’ efforts could also file their own civil complaints as part of the scandal.

It may be difficult to establish a criminal case here; however, the NFL has said it has tens of thousands of pages of evidence to back its argument that the program exists, so there is a possibility that the criminal law will get involved.


http://www.sportsbusinessdaily.com/Journal/Issues/2012/03/12/Leagues-and-Governing-Bodies/Bounty.aspx?hl=scandal%20could%20rise%20to%20criminal%20level&sc=0




No comments:

Post a Comment